Apple Calls Out Musi App's 'Parasitic' Practices in App Store Legal Battle
Apple's legal team has responded to Musi's lawsuit regarding their App Store removal, opposing the preliminary injunction request that would reinstate the app. The dispute centers around Musi's handling of YouTube content and advertising practices.
Apple logo on glass building exterior
Key points from Apple's response:
- Apple can remove apps "at any time, with or without cause" per developer program terms
- YouTube repeatedly contacted Musi about their practices
- IFPI and NMPA support YouTube's position against Musi
According to the NMPA, Musi:
- Uses free YouTube API tokens to avoid licensing fees
- Switches users between tokens when banned
- Masks as iPhone 12 devices to bypass restrictions
- Overlays their own ads on top of YouTube's content
Financial Impact:
- Musi reportedly earned $100M+ in ad revenue (Jan 2023 - Spring 2024)
- Existing users can still access the app and generate revenue
- Apple argues Musi isn't at risk of immediate financial harm
Current users are actively seeking alternatives, with many looking to migrate their playlists to Apple Music or YouTube Music. Musi has not yet responded to Apple's latest filing.
Businessman checking phone with charts
Whitney Houston performing on stage
Fatboy Slim DJing with outstretched arm