Yout Challenges RIAA's Dismissal Motion in YouTube Rolling Cipher Legal Battle
The legal battle between stream-ripper Yout and the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) continues to intensify over YouTube's "rolling cipher" technology.
RIAA logo in monochrome
Yout initiated the lawsuit in October 2020 after the RIAA filed three DMCA takedown requests, claiming Yout circumvents YouTube's rolling cipher protection system. Yout denies these allegations, stating their service doesn't bypass any anti-circumvention technology and automatically blocks protected content.
Key Points of Contention:
- Yout claims the RIAA's takedown notices failed to identify specific protected works
- The platform argues its service extends beyond "stream ripping," focusing primarily on video content from various websites
- Yout maintains that YouTube and common web browsers already allow downloads without circumvention
- The company reports significant damages, including PayPal account termination and lost subscribers due to Google search warnings
Recent Developments: After a judge granted the RIAA's initial motion to dismiss in August, Yout filed an amended complaint. The company now opposes the RIAA's latest motion to dismiss, arguing it's based on "erroneous assumptions and misguided interpretations of law."
Empty courtroom with red drapes
YouTube 3D player buttons interface
Yout, represented by Mudd Law, asserts that the RIAA has shifted from specific claims about the rolling cipher to vague references about YouTube's TPMs (Technological Protection Measures), suggesting a weakening position in their argument.